If you’ve ever checked your home’s value on Zillow or another online estimator, you may have noticed that their estimates change dramatically once a home is listed for sale. That’s because Automated Valuation Models (AVMs) rely on broad data trends—until an agent sets a price. Then, suddenly, Zillow and other AVMs adjust their numbers to reflect that new data point.
So, how accurate are these online estimates when it comes to predicting the actual sale price of a home in Placer County and the greater Sacramento area? Let’s break it down.
The Problem With AVMs
AVMs like Zillow’s Zestimate use public records, recent sales, and proprietary algorithms to generate an estimate. While they can give a general idea of a home’s value, they often miss critical local details that significantly impact pricing, such as:
✅ Recent upgrades and renovations that haven’t been recorded in public data
✅ Buyer demand in specific neighborhoods (Rocklin, Roseville, Loomis, etc.)
✅ Market timing and pricing strategies used by local agents
✅ Unique location factors—does the home have a Folsom Lake view, back to a freeway, or sit near power lines?
In fact, Zillow itself reports that their estimates for off-market homes can be off by 7% or more—which could mean a difference of tens (or even hundreds) of thousands of dollars in Placer County’s competitive housing market.
Why Do Zillow’s Estimates Change After a Home Is Listed?
Before a home is on the market, AVMs rely on broad, impersonal data to generate an estimate. But as soon as a listing price is set—often with the guidance of an experienced real estate agent—the AVM quickly adjusts. This tells us one thing:
Zillow and other AVMs aren’t predicting the market—they’re reacting to it.
How I Use AVMs to Help My Clients
I personally use AVM software to provide regular home value updates for my clients in Placer County and the Sacramento region. These tools help homeowners stay informed about market trends and property values.
However, if you’re considering selling, an automated estimate isn’t enough. That’s why I take a closer look and provide a detailed and informed analysis that accounts for:
✔️ Your home’s actual condition and improvements
✔️ Buyer trends in your specific neighborhood
✔️ Market timing and pricing strategies
✔️ Local competition and recent comparable sales
Want to Know Your Home’s True Market Value?
If you're thinking about selling or just want an expert opinion tailored to your specific neighborhood—whether it’s in Rocklin, Roseville, Loomis, Granite Bay, Auburn, or Lincoln—I’d be happy to provide a professional price analysis based on real market data and firsthand expertise.
Call or text me today at (916) 316-5626 for a free, no-obligation home valuation. Or visit my website below to request a consultation.
Posted by Patrick Hake on
Leave A Comment